You are my brother in the world and the Hereafter
You are my brother in the world and the Hereafter
أنت أخي في الدنيا و الآخرة
You are my brother in the world and the Hereafter.
It is da’if as stated by al Albani.[1]
Hafiz al ‘Iraqi announces, “Everything reported regarding ‘Ali’s brotherhood is da’if.”[2]
You are my brother and minister
أنت أخي و وزيري تقضي ديني و تنجز موعدي و تبرئ ذمتي
You are my brother and minister; you settle my debt, complete my promise, and fulfil my responsibility.
The narrators are majhul. Al Haythami asserts that he is unaware of the narrators.[3]
[1] Da’if al Jami’ Hadith: 1325.
[2] Al Mughni ‘an Haml al Asfar (takhrij of al Ihya’) vol. 1 pg. 493; al Ihya’ vol. 2 pg. 190.
[3] Majma’ al Zawa’id vol. 9 pg. 121.