Difa e Islam | الدفاع عن الإسلام | دفاع الإسلام
Change Language :

Ali: his scale and mines are equal in justice

Ali: his scale and mines are equal in justice

علي كفه و كفي في العدل سواء

‘Ali: his scale and mines are equal in justice.

Another reports has the wording:

كفتي و كف علي في العدل سواء

My scale and ‘Ali’s scale are equal in justice.

This narration is mawdu’. Al Khatib documented it in Tarikh Baghdad[1]. Ahmed al Tammar is responsible. The hadith comes from another chain which is worthless. Qasim al Malti is the only narrator

Qasim al Malti

He would fabricate hadith

His Sheikh is Abu Umayyah al Mukhtit

Al Dhahabi stated, “He is neither reliable nor trustable.”[2]

[1] Tarikh Baghdad vol. 5 pg. 37.

[2] Mizan al I’tidal vol. 1 pg. 290; Lisan al Mizan vol. 1 pg. 286; Silsilat al Ahadith al Da’ifah Hadith: 4897